Download as PDF

Historic Zoning Commission

Fourth and Gill H-1: Level II

11-H-13-HZ

Staff Recommendation

Approve 14'x20' frame garage with steel or fiberglass overhead door that has a framed side-swing appearance, spade strap-hinges and pull handles, and that does not have a faux wood- grain finish. Garage to have wooden board and batten wallcovering, asphalt shingled front-gabled roof of 12x12 pitch with 12-inch eave projection, as per submitted drawings. Garage to be located in rear quadrant of rear (south) yard. Round louvered vent in the front gable to match that on the house.

Location Knoxville
705 Eleanor St 37917
Owner
Nina Nina Phalen; - Egar Smith Egar Smith
Applicant Request
Level II. Construction of addition or outbuilding.
Accessory structure
Approve 14'x20' frame garage with steel or fiberglass overhead door that has a framed side-swing appearance, spade strap-hinges and pull handles, and that does not have a faux wood- grain finish. Garage to have wooden board and batten wallcovering, asphalt shingled front-gabled roof of 12x12 pitch with 12-inch eave projection, as per submitted drawings Garage to be located in rear quadrant of rear (south) yard. Round louvered vent in the front gable to match that on the house.
Staff Comments
Queen Anne (1890)
    Two-story frame with aluminum siding wal covereing . Hip roof with lower cross gables, sawn wood bargeborad. Two-over-two and one-over-one double-hung windows. One-story two-thirds front porch and projecting bay with low sloped turreted roof, shaped sawn wood blustrade, turned wood columns, sawn wood brackets. Interior offset brick chimney. Brick foundation. Irregular plan. Original wood paneled door at front entry. C
OUTBUILDINGS
. . .houses in the district might have had garages, with the same roof shapes and wall coverings, or with wall coverings that matched the primary building on the lot. It is acceptable to construct new outbuildings to the rear of lots on Fourth and Gill, with designs that respect the original designs.

Recommendations:
1. Buildings resembling servants' quarters or carriage houses, work buildings, or simple one story garages are appropriate to be constructed in the Fourth and Gill Historic District. Their size and construction should use materials that correspond to the original primary buildings on the lot.
Applicant

Nina Nina Phalen; - Egar Smith Egar Smith

Planning Staff
Kaye Graybeal
Phone: 215-2500
Email: contact@knoxplanning.org
Submit CommentsView Comments

Case History

    1999

    • September 8, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • September 23, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 6, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 8, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 18, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 20, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 26, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • October 27, 1999
    • Date Filed
    • November 23, 1999
    • Date Filed

    • 2000

    • January 7, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • September 14, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 23, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 24, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • November 2, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2000
    • Date Filed
    • December 4, 2000
    • Date Filed

    • 2001

    • September 11, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 19, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 22, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • November 6, 2001
    • Date Filed
    • November 8, 2001
    • Date Filed

    • 2002

    • September 19, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • September 24, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • September 26, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 18, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 22, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 23, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • November 5, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • November 6, 2002
    • Date Filed
    • November 12, 2002
    • Date Filed

    • 2003

    • February 5, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • September 16, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • September 17, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • September 22, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 1, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 8, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 13, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 14, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 23, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • October 29, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • November 10, 2003
    • Date Filed
    • November 21, 2003
    • Date Filed

    • 2004

    • September 17, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 11, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 19, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 20, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • October 26, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • November 2, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • November 4, 2004
    • Date Filed
    • November 10, 2004
    • Date Filed

    • 2005

    • September 14, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 6, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 10, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 13, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • November 2, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2005
    • Date Filed
    • November 22, 2005
    • Date Filed

    • 2006

    • September 12, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 13, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 20, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • October 27, 2006
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2006
    • Date Filed

    • 2007

    • February 28, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • September 12, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • September 13, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 11, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 15, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 19, 2007
    • Date Filed
    • October 30, 2007
    • Date Filed

    • 2008

    • February 26, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • September 8, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 10, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 14, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 21, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 22, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 27, 2008
    • Date Filed
    • October 28, 2008
    • Date Filed

    • 2009

    • September 8, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • September 14, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 1, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 6, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 13, 2009
    • Date Filed
    • October 22, 2009
    • Date Filed

    • 2010

    • January 19, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • February 23, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 7, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 14, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 15, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 23, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 24, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • October 1, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • November 4, 2010
    • Date Filed
    • November 9, 2010
    • Date Filed

    • 2011

    • January 20, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • February 25, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • April 21, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • September 2, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • September 6, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • September 9, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 6, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 10, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 11, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 18, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2011
    • Date Filed
    • November 9, 2011
    • Date Filed

    • 2012

    • January 17, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • February 27, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • April 17, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 6, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 10, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • October 1, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • October 8, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • October 10, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • October 29, 2012
    • Date Filed
    • November 6, 2012
    • Date Filed

    • 2013

    • April 29, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • September 11, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • September 12, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • October 14, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • October 23, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • November 4, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • November 13, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • November 14, 2013
    • Date Filed
    • December 4, 2013
    • Date Filed

    • 2014

    • April 15, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • September 22, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • October 7, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • October 16, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • October 21, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2014
    • Date Filed
    • November 19, 2014
    • Date Filed

    • 2015

    • September 10, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • September 14, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • September 15, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • September 21, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 6, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 16, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 26, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • October 29, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • November 2, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • November 9, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • November 10, 2015
    • Date Filed
    • November 16, 2015
    • Date Filed

    • 2016

    • September 20, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • September 21, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • October 28, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • November 3, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • November 7, 2016
    • Date Filed
    • November 8, 2016
    • Date Filed

    • 2017

    • September 11, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 16, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 30, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • November 1, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • November 14, 2017
    • Date Filed
    • November 15, 2017
    • Date Filed

    • 2018

    • September 17, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • September 24, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 1, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 9, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 10, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 15, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 18, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • October 23, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • November 6, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • November 29, 2018
    • Date Filed
    • December 11, 2018
    • Date Filed

    • 2019

    • September 10, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • September 11, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • October 21, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • November 4, 2019
    • Date Filed
    • November 22, 2019
    • Date Filed

    • 2020

    • September 11, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 18, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 21, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 22, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 24, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • September 29, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 8, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 15, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 16, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • October 30, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • November 2, 2020
    • Date Filed
    • November 16, 2020
    • Date Filed

    • 2021

    • February 3, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • September 15, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • September 17, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • October 5, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • October 12, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • October 25, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • October 28, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • November 9, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • November 10, 2021
    • Date Filed
    • November 15, 2021
    • Date Filed

    • 2022

    • January 13, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • January 31, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 8, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 16, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 23, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 26, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • September 28, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 18, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 24, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 26, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • November 8, 2022
    • Date Filed
    • November 21, 2022
    • Date Filed

    • 2023

    • January 3, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • October 3, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • October 16, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • October 24, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • November 6, 2023
    • Date Filed
    • December 4, 2023
    • Date Filed

    • 2024

    • February 6, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 11, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 13, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 19, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 20, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 23, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 25, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 27, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • September 30, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • October 2, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • October 4, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • October 14, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • October 17, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • October 31, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • November 4, 2024
    • Date Filed
    • November 19, 2024
    • Date Filed

    • 2025

    • January 6, 2025
    • Date Filed
    • January 28, 2025
    • Date Filed
    • April 17, 2025
    • To be heard